The Ultimate Guide to Long Island’s Top 10 Wedding Venues That Will Make Your Dream Day Unforgettable

I’ll never forget the bride who called me in tears because her “dream venue” hit her with $8,000 in surprise fees three weeks before her wedding. That’s when I realized couples need someone in their corner who’s actually been through this maze.

When I discovered that the average Long Island wedding costs $61,113—nearly double the national average—I knew couples needed more than just a pretty venue list. Look, when you’re dropping the cost of a luxury car on one day, you better make sure it’s perfect. After years of working with brides across Long Island’s most prestigious venues, I’ve witnessed firsthand which locations deliver true value and which ones leave couples with beautiful photos but empty wallets.

Plan your Long Island venue search with our AI Wedding Planner

Quick Resources:

• Plan smarter with our AI Wedding Planner

• Discover all your options with our wedding tools

Long Island’s wedding venue landscape offers everything from historic castles to waterfront estates, but navigating these options requires understanding what separates exceptional venues from merely expensive ones. The wrong choice can impact everything from your guest experience to your marriage’s financial foundation—and trust me, I’ve seen both ends of that spectrum.

TL;DR: Quick Venue Overview

Here’s what you need to know before we dive deep. I’ve worked with couples at each of these places, and these highlights will help you quickly figure out which venues are worth your time.

Westbury Manor is the real deal with their “one wedding at a time” policy—no competing with another bride for bathroom space. Water’s Edge Centerport is brand-new luxury with waterfront views that’ll make your Instagram explode. Oheka Castle is where you go when you want to feel like royalty and have the budget to match—think Great Gatsby but with actual Gatsby money required.

The Inn at New Hyde Park gives you seven different rooms to choose from, so whether you’re having 25 people or 500, they’ve got you covered. Swan Club is basically a photographer’s wet dream with seven acres of gardens that look like they’re straight out of a fairy tale.

Pricing ranges from “okay, we can swing this” ($40K-60K) to “honey, we need to talk to the bank” ($80K+). And here’s the kicker—those seasonal timing differences can save or cost you serious money. Hidden fees are the real budget killer, adding $5,000-15,000 to your final bill with parking charges, overtime fees, and vendor access costs that venues conveniently forget to mention upfront.

Avoid budget surprises with help from our AI Wedding Planner

Exclusive policies mean you won’t be fighting another wedding party for the good bathroom, and weather backup plans aren’t optional on Long Island—Mother Nature doesn’t care about your Pinterest board.

Comparison Table

Venue	Location	Capacity	Exclusivity	Pricing Tier	Best Feature
Westbury Manor	Westbury	200-300	One wedding/day	Mid-High	Victorian Architecture
The Inn at New Hyde Park	New Hyde Park	25-500+	Focused service	Mid-High	Seven event rooms
Water’s Edge Centerport	Centerport	Varies	Complete exclusivity	High	Waterfront views
The Piermont	Babylon	Multiple spaces	Premier status	Mid-High	Great South Bay views
Oheka Castle	Huntington	Up to 400	32 halls available	Ultra-luxury	Historic grandeur
Glen Cove Mansion	Glen Cove	Large celebrations	Full-service luxury	High	187 guest rooms
Hempstead House	Sands Point	30-300	Historic exclusivity	Ultra-luxury	Guggenheim Estate
NYIT de Seversky Mansion	Glen Head	Up to 230	One wedding/day	Mid-High	European architecture
The Bourne Mansion	Oakdale	Up to 400	Estate exclusivity	High	205-acre estate
Swan Club On The Harbor	Roslyn	Up to 325	Gold Coast landmark	High	Seven-acre gardens

What Actually Matters When You’re Venue Shopping (Hint: It’s Not Just Pretty Photos)

Choosing among the best Long Island wedding venues isn’t just about falling in love with pretty pictures online. Trust me, I’ve seen too many couples get swept up in gorgeous photos only to realize they booked a logistical nightmare.

Location accessibility is huge here. Long Island traffic can turn a 20-minute drive into an hour-long ordeal during peak times. I’ve literally watched guests miss entire cocktail hours because they underestimated travel time. If your venue isn’t near major highways (LIE, Northern State, Southern State), your out-of-town guests are going to hate you.

Capacity planning requires precision when you’re paying these prices. Here’s what nobody tells you—most couples underestimate their final guest count by about 20%. Then they’re scrambling to add tables three weeks before the wedding, and suddenly their budget is shot. Figure out your realistic guest count early and build in a 10% buffer, because your cousin’s new boyfriend is definitely coming whether you planned for him or not.

Calculate capacity and budget like a pro with our AI Wedding Planner

Seasonal considerations can make or break your budget. Summer weddings are gorgeous and cost a fortune—we’re talking 30-40% more than off-season. But here’s a secret: fall and winter weddings can be just as stunning with way better pricing. Spring weather is basically Russian roulette, but venues are usually more flexible with both pricing and availability.

The exclusivity factor separates the venues that actually care about your day from the ones treating you like cattle. “One wedding at a time” means you’re not competing with another bride for vendor access, bathroom space, or staff attention. It costs more, but I promise it’s worth every penny.

Hidden fees are where venues really get you. I’ve seen parking fees ($15-25 per car), overtime charges ($200-500 per hour), vendor access fees ($500-1,500), and service charges (18-25% of total bill) add $10,000+ to the final cost. Always—and I mean always—ask for an itemized fee schedule before signing anything.

Uncover hidden fees before booking with our AI Wedding Planner

Westbury Manor: When Victorian Dreams Meet Reality

The first time I walked into Westbury Manor with a bride, she literally started crying. Not because of the price (though that came later), but because it felt exactly like the fairy tale wedding she’d dreamed about since she was seven.

This late 19th-century mansion captures that Victorian romance you see in movies, but it’s the real deal. The Titus House has 18 rooms with original walnut interior that you simply can’t fake in newer venues. But here’s what really sets it apart—their “One Wedding at a Time” policy isn’t just marketing speak. When you book Westbury Manor, the entire property is yours. No shared bathrooms, no competing music, no other bride stealing your photographer’s attention.

What Makes This Place Actually Special

Those multiple gardens aren’t just pretty—they’re your photo shoot locations for the entire day. Ponds, waterfalls, seasonal flowers that look different every time you visit. The main ballroom keeps that Victorian elegance while actually working with modern sound systems (because nobody wants to hear Uncle Bob’s speech through a crackling microphone from 1890).

The mansion’s 18 rooms give you options for every part of your day. Want an intimate ceremony? They’ve got a space. Need room for 200+ reception guests? Covered. And those original architectural details—the carved woodwork, period fixtures—add authenticity that newer venues spend millions trying to replicate.

Why People Love It Here

You get the whole place to yourself, which eliminates about 90% of wedding day stress. No worrying about another bride’s timeline messing with yours, no guests accidentally wandering into someone else’s cocktail hour. The historic architecture is so gorgeous you could literally skip decorations and still look incredible.

The central Long Island location means your guests from Nassau and Suffolk counties won’t hate the drive. And vendors know this place inside and out, which means fewer surprises on your wedding day.

The Reality Check

If your style is more “modern minimalist” than “Victorian romance,” this might feel like you’re playing dress-up in someone else’s house. The historic building can be limiting for certain types of entertainment—don’t expect to install a massive DJ booth with laser lights.

Weather backup is crucial for outdoor ceremonies, though their indoor alternatives are actually beautiful. And that exclusive policy everyone loves? It means booking 12-18 months out for prime dates.

My Honest Rating

• Location & Accessibility: 5/5 – Central Long Island with easy highway access
• Capacity: 4/5 – Great for most weddings, not so much for massive celebrations
• Seasonal Appeal: 5/5 – Those gardens look incredible year-round
• Exclusivity: 5/5 – True one-wedding-at-a-time policy
• Value: 4/5 – Mid-to-high luxury pricing with serious amenities included

What Couples Actually Say

The reviews consistently mention the romantic atmosphere and stress-free experience of having the place to themselves. Photographers love recommending it because of the diverse photo opportunities and gorgeous natural lighting throughout the day.

Source: WeddingWire and venue testimonials

The Bottom Line on Pricing

Mid-to-high luxury pricing that reflects the exclusive access and historic charm. Packages typically include ceremony and reception spaces, tables, chairs, and basic linens. Upgrades like premium florals and extended hours are available but add up fast.

Visit Westbury Manor’s website for detailed pricing and availability.

The Inn at New Hyde Park: Where the Food Actually Matters

Since 1938, The Inn at New Hyde Park has built its reputation on one simple truth—bad wedding food ruins everything. Their culinary team brings over 200 years of combined experience, and honestly, it shows. I’ve never had a couple complain about the food here, which is saying something in the wedding world.

But here’s what really makes this place special: seven different rooms. Whether you’re planning an intimate gathering of 25 or a grand celebration for 500+, they’ve literally got a space that fits. No more “well, we could squeeze everyone in if Aunt Martha doesn’t bring a plus-one” stress.

Why This Place Actually Works

Italian marble and stone throughout create that understated elegance that photographs beautifully without feeling stuffy. The ballrooms have high ceilings and sophisticated lighting, while the private garden courtyards offer intimate outdoor ceremony options that don’t feel like an afterthought.

The professional event planning teams work exclusively with Inn couples, bringing decades of experience to every celebration. And their established vendor relationships often mean better pricing and priority scheduling—which is gold in the Long Island wedding world.

The Real Advantages

Incredible flexibility means you won’t outgrow your venue if your guest list expands (and it will). The award-winning food eliminates one major wedding worry—nobody’s going to be talking about how terrible dinner was. Multiple venue options within one location provide backup plans and diverse photo opportunities.

The venue’s reputation attracts experienced wedding professionals who know exactly how everything works here. Less coordination headaches, fewer day-of surprises.

What Might Drive You Crazy

High demand means booking 12-18 months out for prime dates. The premium full-service experience costs accordingly—if you’re trying to DIY everything to save money, this might not be your place. Some rooms can feel formal if you’re going for a laid-back vibe.

The popularity can sometimes result in a “we’ve seen this before” feeling if you don’t work closely with planners to make it personal.

My Honest Rating

• Location & Accessibility: 5/5 – Established central location since 1938
• Capacity: 5/5 – Seven rooms accommodate 25 to 500+ guests
• Seasonal Appeal: 5/5 – Indoor and outdoor options work year-round
• Exclusivity: 4/5 – **Focused service with dedicated planning teams
• Value: 5/5 – The food quality alone justifies the pricing

What People Really Think

Couples consistently rave about the food quality and professional service. Many mention the venue’s ability to handle last-minute changes and dietary restrictions without drama. Wedding planners recommend it for couples who want everything done right the first time.

Source: The Knot and Google Reviews

The Money Talk

Mid-to-high-end pricing that varies significantly based on room choice and guest count. Various package options from basic to comprehensive planning services. Off-season dates offer substantial savings, while premium dates cost accordingly.

Contact The Inn at New Hyde Park for specific pricing based on your needs.

Water’s Edge Centerport: Brand New and Worth the Hype

Water’s Edge Centerport is the new kid on the block, and they’re not messing around. This place combines Gatsby-era glamour with contemporary amenities, creating something that feels both timeless and totally current. The waterfront location provides views that change throughout the day—morning ceremonies feel fresh and hopeful, while sunset receptions are pure romance.

The exclusive access policy here isn’t just marketing—they really do focus entirely on your wedding when you book their space. It’s like having your own private waterfront estate for the day.

What Makes This Place Stand Out

Those waterfront views are the real star, with floor-to-ceiling windows that maximize the natural beauty of the Gold Coast setting. The indoor furnishings complement rather than compete with the outdoor scenery, creating that seamless indoor-outdoor flow everyone wants but rarely gets.

The gourmet on-site cuisine focuses on fresh, locally-sourced ingredients that actually make sense with the waterfront setting. Grand event rooms work for various celebration styles, while bridal and groom suites on the top floor give you private spaces to breathe and get ready.

Why People Are Obsessed

Everything is brand new and in pristine condition—no worn carpets or outdated sound systems here. Modern infrastructure supports all the contemporary entertainment requirements, from advanced sound systems to sophisticated lighting. The exclusive use policy eliminates all those venue-sharing nightmares.

The team’s 20+ years of combined experience means they know what they’re doing despite being the new venue on the block. And those waterfront settings provide naturally stunning photo opportunities that require minimal additional decoration.

Explore new venues with confidence using our AI Wedding Planner

The Potential Downsides

Limited track record means fewer reviews and testimonials from actual couples. Premium pricing for the luxury experience might not fit all budgets, especially when Long Island weddings are already expensive. Weather dependency for waterfront elements requires solid backup planning.

The modern aesthetic might not appeal if you’re dreaming of historic charm or rustic vibes. Limited availability due to exclusive policies means booking well in advance is essential.

My Honest Rating

• Location & Accessibility: 5/5 – Prime Gold Coast waterfront location
• Capacity: 4/5 – Handles intimate to grand celebrations well
• Seasonal Appeal: 5/5 – Waterfront views are stunning year-round
• Exclusivity: 5/5 – Complete venue exclusivity for your day
• Value: 5/5 – Modern luxury with exceptional service standards

Early Reviews and Feedback

Early couples praise the modern amenities and stunning waterfront views. Wedding photographers are highlighting the exceptional natural lighting and diverse photo opportunities. Industry professionals note the attention to detail and professional service standards.

Source: Early venue testimonials and industry feedback

Investment Information

High-end luxury pricing reflects the modern amenities and exclusive waterfront location. Packages typically include venue access, basic amenities, and coordination services. Premium add-ons for enhanced florals, upgraded catering, and extended hours are available.

Explore options at Water’s Edge Centerport for detailed pricing.

The Piermont: Great South Bay Waterfront Excellence

Listen, I’ve been to a lot of waterfront venues that promise “stunning bay views” and deliver a glimpse of water if you crane your neck just right. The Piermont isn’t one of those places. When they say Great South Bay views, they mean you’re literally sitting on the water watching sailboats drift by during cocktail hour.

I remember one couple who booked here specifically because the groom proposed on a boat in this exact bay. Cheesy? Maybe. But watching their faces light up every time they looked out those ballroom windows? Totally worth it.

What Makes This Place Special (And What Doesn’t)

The waterfront location is obviously the star here—I mean, you’re paying for those views, so they better be good. And they are. The way the light changes on the water throughout the day gives you completely different vibes from ceremony to reception. Morning ceremonies feel fresh and hopeful, while sunset receptions are pure romance.

But here’s the reality check: waterfront venues come with waterfront problems. I’ve seen ceremonies moved indoors because of sudden wind gusts that would’ve blown the bride’s veil into the next county. Always, and I mean always, have a solid backup plan.

The Good Stuff

Your Instagram is going to be fire—those sunset shots over the bay are magazine-worthy without even trying. The venue team actually knows what they’re doing with waterfront events (trust me, not all of them do). And if you’ve got guests coming from the city, the water views make the Long Island trek feel worth it.

The Reality Check

Summer weekends book up faster than Taylor Swift tickets, and they price accordingly. If your heart is set on a July Saturday, start looking yesterday and bring your checkbook. Also, Mother Nature doesn’t care about your wedding budget—weather contingency plans are non-negotiable here.

My Honest Rating

• Location & Accessibility: 5/5 – Prime Great South Bay waterfront location
• Capacity: 5/5 – Multiple spaces accommodate various celebration sizes
• Seasonal Appeal: 5/5 – Waterfront beauty enhanced by seasonal changes
• Exclusivity: 4/5 – Premier waterfront destination status
• Value: 4/5 – Waterfront luxury pricing with comprehensive amenities

My Honest Take: If waterfront views are your non-negotiable and you’ve got the budget for it, The Piermont delivers. Just don’t expect it to be cheap, and definitely have Plan B ready.

Contact The Piermont through venue directories for specific pricing and availability information.

Oheka Castle: When You Want to Feel Like Royalty (And Pay Like It)

Okay, let’s just get this out of the way—Oheka Castle is stupid expensive. Like, “I could buy a Tesla instead of having my wedding here” expensive. But holy crap, is it spectacular.

I’ll never forget the first time I walked a bride through those doors. She literally gasped and then immediately started crying. Happy tears, but still. The place has that effect on people. It’s not just a venue; it’s like stepping into a movie set where you’re the star.

Why People Lose Their Minds Over This Place

Built in 1915, this isn’t some fake castle thrown up for weddings. This is the real deal—127 rooms, 32 different event spaces, and enough grandeur to make Downton Abbey look modest. The Great Gatsby connection isn’t just marketing fluff; F. Scott Fitzgerald actually hung out here.

The Grand Ballroom makes most people feel like they should curtsy when they walk in. Crystal chandeliers, soaring ceilings, and details that probably cost more than most people’s entire weddings. It’s extra in the best possible way.

The Amazing Parts

You get to stay on the property, which means no awkward “where’s the after-party?” moments. Your wedding photos will look like they belong in a museum. And let’s be honest—your friends will be talking about your wedding for years.

The staff treats you like actual royalty, which is nice when you’re paying royal prices. They’ve got this whole thing down to a science.

The “But Actually” Parts

Unless you’re comfortable dropping $80K+ just on the venue, keep scrolling. Even if you are, book about two years out because everyone and their mother wants to get married here.

Also, and I cannot stress this enough—the castle is HUGE. Like, your 90-year-old great-aunt might need a GPS to find the bathroom. It’s gorgeous but not exactly intimate.

My Honest Rating

• Location & Accessibility: 4/5 – Huntington location with historic significance
• Capacity: 5/5 – Multiple rooms accommodate up to 400 guests
• Seasonal Appeal: 5/5 – Castle and gardens stunning in every season
• Exclusivity: 5/5 – 32 individually designed halls offer unique experiences
• Value: 3/5 – Ultra-luxury pricing for once-in-a-lifetime experience

Bottom Line: If you’ve got the budget and want a wedding that’s basically a real-life fairy tale, this is it. If you’re looking for cozy and intimate, maybe not so much.

Visit Oheka Castle at 135 W Gate Dr, Huntington, NY 11743 for exclusive consultation and pricing information.

Glen Cove Mansion: When You Want Everything in One Place

This place is basically the Swiss Army knife of wedding venues—it does everything. Ceremony space? Check. Reception hall? Check. Hotel rooms for your entire wedding party? Double check. It’s like wedding planning on easy mode.

I love recommending Glen Cove to couples who are already stressed about coordinating seventeen different vendors across five different locations. When everything’s under one roof, life gets a whole lot simpler.

What Makes It Work

Those 187 guest rooms mean nobody’s driving home after your open bar. Your wedding party can get ready on-site, your ceremony and reception flow seamlessly, and your hungover college friends can stumble to brunch the next morning without calling an Uber.

The 55 acres give you room to breathe and about a million photo opportunities. Georgian architecture is classic for a reason—it photographs beautifully and never looks dated.

The Wins

One-stop shopping for your entire wedding weekend. No “will the shuttle be on time?” stress. Your out-of-town guests will actually thank you for making their lives easier. And the coordination team has their act together because they literally do this every weekend.

The Watch-Outs

It can feel a bit… corporate? Like, professional and polished, but maybe not super personal. If you’re dreaming of a quirky, unique vibe, this might feel too buttoned-up.

Also, when I say “everything included,” I mean everything’s available—not necessarily everything’s affordable. Those extras add up fast.

My Honest Rating

• Location & Accessibility: 5/5 – Convenient location with airport proximity
• Capacity: 5/5 – 187 guest rooms accommodate large celebrations
• Seasonal Appeal: 5/5 – Georgian mansion beautiful throughout the year
• Exclusivity: 4/5 – Full-service luxury experience with dedicated attention
• Value: 4/5 – Comprehensive packages include accommodations

Real Talk: Perfect for couples who want a beautiful, stress-free wedding without playing logistics coordinator for six months.

Contact Glen Cove Mansion at 200 Dosoris Ln, Glen Cove, NY 11542 for comprehensive pricing and availability.

Hempstead House: Guggenheim Money, Guggenheim Problems

Walking onto the Guggenheim Estate feels like you’ve somehow time-traveled to the 1920s when having stupid amounts of money was basically a hobby. This place drips old-money elegance in a way that’s both incredible and slightly intimidating.

I’ve had brides tell me they felt like they needed to practice their posture before their wedding here. It’s that fancy.

The Guggenheim Factor

This isn’t just any mansion—this was the Guggenheim family’s actual home. You’re getting married where some of America’s wealthiest families threw parties that probably cost more than most people’s houses. The history is real, the architecture is stunning, and the Long Island Sound views are chef’s kiss perfect.

Castle Gould adds this whole Celtic castle vibe that’s completely different but somehow works perfectly with the main mansion. It’s like getting two venues in one.

What You’ll Love

The exclusivity factor is off the charts. Your friends will be impressed before they even see your dress. Those Sound views during cocktail hour? Unmatched. And the Rose Garden ceremonies are so romantic they make Disney movies look cynical.

What Might Drive You Crazy

Historic venues come with historic venue problems. Want to hang string lights everywhere? Maybe not happening. Dream of a DJ booth that lights up like a spaceship? Probably not the vibe they’re going for.

Also, “historic preservation” is code for “some stuff might not work the way you expect it to.” Just saying.

My Honest Rating

• Location & Accessibility: 4/5 – Historic Guggenheim Estate location with Sound access
• Capacity: 5/5 – Accommodates 30 to 300 guests across multiple spaces
• Seasonal Appeal: 5/5 – 216-acre park with gardens stunning year-round
• Exclusivity: 5/5 – Historic estate exclusivity creates unique experiences
• Value: 3/5 – Premium pricing for unmatched historic significance

My Take: If you want to feel like old-money royalty for a day and you’ve got the budget to match, this is your spot. Just be ready to work within some pretty specific guidelines.

Visit Hempstead House at 127 Middle Neck Rd, Sands Point, NY 11050 for historic venue consultation and pricing.

NYIT de Seversky Mansion: European Vibes Without the Passport

This place makes you feel like you should be speaking with a slight accent and dramatically throwing your coat to a butler. Built in 1918, it’s got that European mansion thing down pat—marble everywhere, intricate mosaics, and gardens that look like they belong in a period drama.

The “one wedding per day” policy here isn’t just marketing—they really do shut down everything else for you. It’s like having your own private estate for the day, which is pretty cool when you think about it.

The European Dream

That marble foyer with the grand staircase? Pure drama in the best way. I’ve seen grown men tear up walking their daughters down those stairs. The mosaic work throughout the building is actual art—not the fake stuff you see in newer venues trying to look fancy.

The gardens have that perfectly imperfect European thing going on—manicured but not stuffy, with fountains that actually work and don’t look like they came from a garden center.

Why It Works

You get the whole place to yourself, which means no rushing because another wedding is setting up in the next room. The architecture does most of your decorating for you—seriously, the building is so beautiful you could skip flowers entirely and still look amazing.

Plus, 230 guests is the perfect size—big enough for a real party, small enough that you can actually talk to people.

The Reality Check

European elegance is gorgeous, but it’s not for everyone. If your style is more “rustic barn” or “modern minimalist,” this might feel like you’re playing dress-up in someone else’s house.

And that one-wedding-per-day thing? It means they’re not booking three weddings to split their overhead. The exclusivity costs extra.

My Honest Rating

• Location & Accessibility: 4/5 – Glen Head location in central Long Island
• Capacity: 4/5 – Accommodates up to 230 guests comfortably
• Seasonal Appeal: 5/5 – European gardens and architecture beautiful year-round
• Exclusivity: 5/5 – True one-wedding-per-day exclusivity policy
• Value: 4/5 – Historic elegance at reasonable luxury pricing

Bottom Line: Perfect for couples who want something elegant and intimate without feeling like they’re in a wedding factory.

Contact NYIT de Seversky Mansion at Northern Blvd, Glen Head, NY 11545 for exclusive consultation and availability.

The Bourne Mansion: When Bigger Is Actually Better

Two hundred and five acres. Let that sink in for a minute. Most venues brag about having “spacious grounds” when they’ve got maybe five acres. The Bourne Mansion is basically a small country with a really nice house in the middle.

This place doesn’t mess around—it’s pure Gilded Age excess, and they’re not apologizing for it. If you’ve ever wanted to feel like a robber baron throwing the party of the century, this is your moment.

The Scale of This Place

That Grand Ballroom isn’t just big—it’s “you might need a microphone to talk to your wedding party” big. High ceilings with gilded everything, and enough space that you could probably fit most people’s entire weddings in just the cocktail area.

The grounds are insane. I’ve had couples do their engagement photos, ceremony, cocktail hour, and reception photos all in completely different locations without ever leaving the property.

What’s Actually Amazing

You can invite literally everyone you’ve ever met and still have room for more. The Great Gatsby vibes are real—not fake movie-set Gatsby, but actual “we have more money than sense” 1920s energy.

Everything you need is included—tables, chairs, linens, china. When you’re dealing with 400 guests, not having to coordinate rentals is a genuine blessing.

The Less Amazing Parts

It’s an hour and a half from the city, which means your NYC friends are going to complain. A lot. And when I say it’s big, I mean some of your guests might literally get lost trying to find the bathroom.

Also, this level of grandeur can feel overwhelming if you’re more of a “small intimate gathering” person. There’s no making this place feel cozy.

My Honest Rating

• Location & Accessibility: 4/5 – Oakdale location requires travel planning from NYC
• Capacity: 5/5 – Accommodates up to 400 reception guests, 300 dinner
• Seasonal Appeal: 5/5 – Great Gatsby era grandeur enhanced by seasonal changes
• Exclusivity: 4/5 – Impressive estate setting with dedicated attention
• Value: 4/5 – Includes essential rentals in comprehensive packages

Real Talk: If you want to go big or go home, this is going big. Just make sure your guest list can handle the scale.

Contact The Bourne Mansion at 500 County Rd 85 #2, Oakdale, NY 11769 for estate consultation and pricing details.

Swan Club: The Instagram Dream

Seven acres of gardens designed specifically to make every photo look like it belongs in a wedding magazine. I’m not even exaggerating—I’ve never met a photographer who didn’t love shooting here.

The cascading waterfalls, multiple gazebos, and perfectly manicured everything create this whole fairy tale garden vibe that’s almost too pretty to be real. Almost.

Why Photographers Lose Their Minds Here

Every corner of this place is designed to be photogenic. Not just pretty—actually designed with photos in mind. The lighting is perfect, the backgrounds are varied, and you could spend your entire wedding day just taking pictures and never run out of gorgeous spots.

The Camelot ballroom overlooks all those gardens, so even during dinner, your guests are looking out at something beautiful.

The Amazing Stuff

Your wedding photos will be incredible without you even trying. The natural beauty means you can spend less on decorations and still have everything look lush and romantic. Multiple ceremony locations give you options based on your guest count and style.

The North Shore location is gorgeous and accessible without being too far from civilization.

The Potential Issues

“Photographer’s paradise” often means “weather dependent nightmare.” Those gorgeous gardens don’t look quite as magical in a downpour. Make sure you love the indoor backup options as much as the outdoor ones.

Prime dates book fast and cost accordingly. If you want those perfect spring blooms or fall colors, you’re competing with every other couple who follows wedding Instagram accounts.

My Honest Rating

• Location & Accessibility: 5/5 – Prime North Shore Roslyn Harbor location
• Capacity: 5/5 – Accommodates up to 325 guests in Camelot ballroom
• Seasonal Appeal: 5/5 – Seven-acre gardens with seasonal beauty variations
• Exclusivity: 4/5 – Gold Coast landmark setting with dedicated service
• Value: 4/5 – Comprehensive planning included with garden paradise setting

My Honest Opinion: If having incredible photos is your top priority and you’re okay with the premium price tag, this place delivers. Just have a solid rain plan.

Visit Swan Club On The Harbor at 90 Glenwood Rd, Roslyn, NY 11576 for garden venue consultation and availability.

Notable Mentions That Deserve Some Love

Look, not everyone needs to get married in a castle or spend their kids’ college fund on one day. These places might not have made the top ten, but they’re still pretty fantastic options.

Flowerfield (St. James)

This gorgeous 12-acre private estate captivates couples with lovely fruit orchards, water fountains, and a 6,000 sq ft ball room. The signature Gazebo Island ceremonies surrounded by a pond create fairy-tale moments, while award-winning catering services ensure exceptional dining experiences. It’s like the cool younger sister of the fancy venues—gorgeous but less pretentious. Learn more about Flowerfield.

Jericho Terrace (Mineola)

Five ballrooms and two cocktail rooms provide incredible flexibility for celebrations of any size. The venue’s colorful gardens and stunning terrace featuring seasonal flowers and waterfalls create natural beauty, while award-winning cuisine consistently earns rave reviews from couples and guests. It’s either awesome flexibility or decision paralysis, depending on your personality. Explore Jericho Terrace options.

Fox Hollow (Woodbury)

This sumptuous eight-acre manor combines celebrated history with impressive mansion architecture, featuring waterfalls and country park settings. The venue accommodates 50 to 285 visitors and includes an all-suite deluxe hotel with gourmet restaurant for comprehensive celebration experiences. It’s like Glen Cove’s more relaxed cousin. Discover Fox Hollow amenities.

Larkfield (East Northport)

Stylish venue design combines modern amenities with Old World romance inspired by Tuscan Villages. Two distinctive ballrooms (Serano and Borgese) accommodate up to 400 guests, while well-maintained orchards provide beautiful outdoor ceremony and photo opportunities. It feels like you’re getting married in an actual Tuscan village, but without the international travel and jet lag. View Larkfield details.

The Questions Everyone Actually Wants to Ask

Common questions about Long Island wedding venues address timing, costs, capacity planning, seasonal considerations, and booking strategies. Here’s the real talk on what couples need to know.

When Do I Actually Need to Start Looking?

Yesterday. No, seriously—if you want a Saturday in June at any of these places, you need to start looking 12-18 months out. Maybe longer for places like Oheka Castle.

But here’s a secret: if you’re flexible on dates, you can find amazing deals. Thursday weddings, Sunday brunches, off-season celebrations—the venues are the same, but your wallet will thank you. Winter and early spring weddings offer more flexibility with 6-12 month advance booking, plus significant cost savings compared to peak season rates.

What’s This Actually Going to Cost Me?

Brace yourself. We’re talking 40-50% of your entire wedding budget just for the venue. On Long Island, that means anywhere from $35K to $100K+. And that’s before all the surprise fees they don’t mention in the pretty brochures.

Pro tip: Ask for an itemized breakdown of every possible fee. Parking, overtime, vendor access, service charges—all of it. I’ve seen couples get hit with an extra $10K in fees they never saw coming. Budget an additional 20% buffer for unexpected costs and upgrades that often arise during planning.

Indoor or Outdoor Ceremony?

Here’s the thing about outdoor ceremonies on Long Island—the weather is basically a coin flip from April through October. I’ve seen perfect 75-degree days turn into surprise thunderstorms in about twenty minutes.

If you’re dead set on outdoor, make sure the indoor backup doesn’t make you want to cry. Because you might need it. Consider your guest demographics, season, and backup preferences when deciding. Many couples choose venues offering both options, allowing flexibility based on weather conditions and personal preferences that may evolve during planning.

What Should I Actually Ask During Tours?

Forget the pretty stuff for a minute. Ask the hard questions: What happens if it rains? How much is parking really going to cost my guests? Can I use my own vendors or am I stuck with their preferred list? What time does everything have to be cleaned up?

And here’s a big one—ask to see the space set up for an actual wedding, not just the empty room. It looks totally different with 200 people, tables, and a dance floor. Focus on logistics beyond the pretty spaces: What are the exact fees for parking, overtime, and vendor access? What’s included in quoted prices versus additional charges? How do they handle weather contingencies? What are their policies on decorations, music volume, and celebration end times?

Does Exclusivity Actually Matter?

Yes. Oh my god, yes. I cannot tell you how many weddings I’ve seen ruined by having to share bathrooms, parking, and staff attention with another event.

“One wedding at a time” venues cost more, but the stress they save you is worth every penny. Exclusivity policies dramatically impact your wedding day experience and should be a primary consideration. Shared venues may offer lower pricing but often result in compromised service quality and guest experience, particularly during peak wedding season.

For couples considering whether they need bridesmaids, professional support can be invaluable during the venue selection process.

My Final, Honest Take on All of This

After dealing with Long Island venues for years, here’s what I really think:

The exclusivity thing isn’t just nice-to-have—it’s essential. Shared venues are a nightmare waiting to happen.

Those hidden fees will get you every time. Budget an extra 20% for stuff they didn’t mention.

Weather backup plans aren’t optional on Long Island. Mother Nature doesn’t care about your Pinterest board.

Historic venues are gorgeous but come with old-building problems. Modern venues have better amenities but less character. Pick your compromise.

Waterfront is beautiful but expensive and weather-dependent. Gardens are Instagram gold but high-maintenance. Ballrooms are reliable but sometimes boring.

The truth is, most of these venues will give you a beautiful wedding if you plan properly and budget realistically. The “perfect” venue is the one that fits your actual priorities, not the one that looks best on Instagram.

Find the perfect match for your priorities with our AI Wedding Planner

And honestly? Your guests will remember how they felt at your wedding, not whether the ceiling had crown molding or if the gardens had exactly the right flowers. Pick a place you love, plan for the unexpected, and focus on marrying the person you’re crazy about.

Understanding the difference between wedding planners and professional bridesmaids can help couples determine what type of support they need during venue planning.

Planning a Long Island wedding involves countless decisions and coordination challenges that can feel overwhelming, especially when managing family expectations and vendor logistics. This is where Bridesmaid for Hire’s professional services become invaluable. Our experienced team understands Long Island’s venue landscape intimately and can provide the support you need throughout your planning journey.

From helping coordinate vendor schedules at complex venues to ensuring your timeline runs smoothly during waterfront celebrations at The Piermont, our professional bridesmaids bring industry expertise and calm presence to your special day. We’ve worked at venues across Long Island and understand the unique requirements each location presents.

For additional support during your celebration, consider our expert tips from professional bridesmaids who have experience at Long Island’s top venues.

Ready to make your Long Island wedding dreams a reality? Contact Bridesmaid for Hire today to learn how our professional wedding support services can ensure your celebration unfolds flawlessly, regardless of which stunning venue you choose.

The venue is just the backdrop. You’re the story.